From “Idol-Breaking” to “Idol-Embracing” The Voice of the Afghan People Against the Taliban’s Ideological and Political Contradictions
- Condemnation of Cultural Crimes
- Historical and Cultural Context of the Bamiyan Tragedy
- Condemnation of the Ban on Women’s and Girls’ Education
- Violation of Human Rights
- Political Consequences of Educational Deprivation
- Weakening of Women’s Economic Contribution
- Domestic Political Pressure and Social Resistance
- International Isolation
- Islamic Principles and the Legitimacy of Education
- Cultural Heritage and Political Legitimacy in Afghanistan
- Call for Support from Civil Societies
- Urgent Appeal to International Organizations
- A Call to Save Afghanistan’s Next Generation
Issued on behalf of the Afghan people, the Law and Justice Civil Movement releases this declaration in defense of human conscience, cultural identity, and women’s right to education and freedom.
Condemnation of Cultural Crimes
We firmly condemn the historical and cultural tragedy of 2001, when the Taliban regime committed an irreversible act of cultural destruction by demolishing the ancient Buddhas of Bamiyan. This act was not merely an assault on Afghanistan’s cultural heritage but a blatant crime against the shared civilization of humanity. The Buddhas of Bamiyan stood as enduring symbols of centuries-old artistic mastery, religious tolerance, and cultural coexistence.
Yet today, the very movement that once destroyed this heritage under the pretext of “idolatry” and “infidelity” now holds press conferences and seeks international legitimacy under the shadow of those same cultural relics. This hypocrisy reflects the Taliban’s intellectual, ideological, and political contradictions from idol-breaking to idol-embracing.Yet today, the very movement that once destroyed this heritage under the pretext of “idolatry” and “infidelity” now holds press conferences and seeks international legitimacy under the shadow of those same cultural relics. This hypocrisy reflects the Taliban’s intellectual, ideological, and political contradictions from idol-breaking to idol-embracing.
Historical and Cultural Context of the Bamiyan Tragedy
Human history has been shaped through art, religious tolerance, and cultural heritage. Every region of the world reflects the richness of human civilization through its monuments and historical symbols and Afghanistan has long held a unique place in this regard.
The Buddhas of Bamiyan, located in central Afghanistan, were masterpieces of Buddhist civilization not only for Afghanistan but for all humanity. These monumental statues symbolized the intellectual depth, artistic brilliance, and religious tolerance of ancient societies.
However, in 2001, the Taliban regime committed a historic and cultural atrocity by destroying these unparalleled monuments. Their act was not only an attack on Afghan heritage but an open crime against global civilization. By erasing these monuments, the regime sought to erase a chapter of history, silencing an artistic and cultural testimony that connected generations.
The destruction of Bamiyan’s Buddhas was not merely the loss of stone sculptures it was the annihilation of a civilization’s artistic and spiritual legacy, built over centuries. These statues embodied the region’s cultural diversity, interfaith coexistence, and human creativity.
The Taliban justified this act under the pretext of religion labeling the statues as symbols of “idolatry” and “infidelity.” Yet such reasoning exposes a profound intellectual crisis. Destroying a nation’s cultural and historical wealth under religious guise represents a distorted ideology serving both political and authoritarian motives.
The international community overwhelmingly condemned the destruction. UNESCO and other global cultural organizations documented it as one of the gravest examples of cultural heritage annihilation in modern history. The tragedy not only deprived Afghanistan of priceless artistic treasures but also diminished its international reputation, political credibility, and cultural identity.
Today, paradoxically, the same movement that destroyed history now seeks recognition under its remnants a vivid demonstration of ideological inconsistency and duplicity. The Taliban’s transformation “from idol-breaking to idol-embracing” will remain an enduring symbol of hypocrisy and contradiction in modern history.
Preserving cultural heritage is not merely a duty to the past it is a moral and human obligation toward future generations. The destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas reminds us that safeguarding art, history, and cultural diversity is vital for social stability, intellectual freedom, and the progress of civilization. If humanity fails to protect such heritage, the foundations of identity, diversity, and trust among nations will be gravely weakened.
Hence, the demolition of the Bamiyan Buddhas serves as a permanent lesson in history. We must condemn such crimes, take concrete steps to preserve cultural heritage, and assure future generations that humanity’s shared civilization remains protected. This condemnation is not only a remembrance of a tragic event but also a defense of cultural tolerance, human rights, and universal principles. The wounds of history teach us that the preservation of humanity, art, and culture is a shared global responsibility.
Condemnation of the Ban on Women’s and Girls’ Education
The Taliban’s continued prohibition on girls’ education and women’s employment is in direct violation of all international human rights principles. Education is both a divine command and a fundamental human right. Any regime that closes the doors of knowledge condemns the nation’s future to ignorance and uncertainty.
We therefore strongly denounce this injustice and call upon the authorities to:
Immediately and unconditionally reopen all schools and universities for girls.
Guarantee women’s rights to work, education, and social participation throughout Afghanistan.
Violation of Human Rights
The Taliban’s restrictions on women’s and girls’ rights to education and employment constitute a clear breach of international human rights law, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Convention on the Rights of the Child, and the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW).
Politically, this ongoing repression further erodes the Taliban’s international legitimacy and isolates Afghanistan from the global community.
Political Consequences of Educational Deprivation
Education forms the foundation of a nation’s future. The restriction on girls’ and women’s education leads to a loss of human capital and halts social and economic progress. Politically, such prohibitions pose a serious threat to the long-term stability of governance, as an educated generation is the driving force behind social reform and economic growth.
Weakening of Women’s Economic Contribution
Limiting women’s participation in the workforce weakens the overall economic capacity of society. It not only reduces household income but also slows down national development. In global relations, such policies result in reduced foreign aid and the suspension of development projects, further deepening Afghanistan’s economic isolation.
Domestic Political Pressure and Social Resistance
Restrictions on girls’ education and women’s employment have sparked domestic opposition and resistance from civil society and women’s rights groups. Politically, these measures threaten internal stability, as social injustice and gender discrimination can lead to unrest and the erosion of public trust.
International Isolation
Violations of women’s rights have severely damaged Afghanistan’s relations with the international community. Possible sanctions, reduced aid, and the loss of legitimacy have left the Taliban regime in a state of political and diplomatic isolation. This situation undermines both the government’s economic stability and its global credibility.
Islamic Principles and the Legitimacy of Education
Islam explicitly emphasizes that the pursuit of knowledge is a divine command and a natural human right bestowed by Allah (SWT). The Taliban’s ban on girls’ education under the pretext of Sharia contradicts the scholarly interpretations of Islamic jurisprudence, which recognize education as a legitimate right for women. This ideological inconsistency creates a serious political gap and exposes the regime to domestic and international criticism.
The ban on girls’ education and women’s employment is not merely a human rights issue — it carries profound implications for Afghanistan’s political legitimacy, economic development, and international relations. These actions invite both domestic discontent and international pressure on the Taliban’s governance.The Law and Justice Civil Movement’s Political Analysis
Cultural Heritage and Political Legitimacy in Afghanistan
In today’s interconnected world, global politics and diplomacy directly shape the lives of nations. International organizations such as the United Nations, the European Union, and major powers claim to act in defense of peace, justice, and human rights. However, their policies often reveal double standards, undermining the credibility of the very principles they promote.
Afghanistan has, over the past decades, become a vivid example of such contradictions particularly concerning cultural preservation, political legitimacy, and human justice.
We therefore pose a question to the international community especially to the United Nations, the European Union, and those governments engaging with the Taliban:
How can those responsible for destroying Afghanistan’s cultural and historical heritage now enjoy political recognition under the shadow of the very monuments they destroyed?
This question is not only for the Afghan people but for the conscience of the entire international order.
Firstly, the protection of cultural heritage is inseparable from the identity, history, and future of any nation. Afghanistan, home to one of the world’s oldest civilizations, possesses an extraordinary range of historic sites and artistic treasures. The destruction of these monuments is not only the erasure of a people’s memory but a grave assault on global cultural diversity and collective human heritage.
When the international community turns a blind eye or grants legitimacy to those responsible for such acts, it effectively undermines the moral and legal foundations of international norms.
Secondly, the issue of political legitimacy reveals another side of this double standard. While international organizations and powerful states claim to promote democracy, peace, and human rights, their selective engagement for political convenience damages the credibility of international justice.
In Afghanistan, granting recognition to a group that has violated women’s rights, suppressed education, and destroyed cultural heritage epitomizes these contradictions.
Thirdly, these double standards deepen the wounds of the Afghan people. The global community’s selective memory adds insult to injury. When political interests overshadow justice, victims’ voices are silenced, and moral accountability is lost.
Fourthly, the persistence of these double standards stems from conflicting geopolitical and economic interests particularly those related to security, trade, and natural resources. As a result, international institutions often act under political pressure, placing humanitarian principles as secondary priorities.
Fifthly, the criticism of these double standards is not merely about Afghanistan. It calls into question the credibility and legitimacy of global institutions themselves. If powerful nations
and international bodies apply principles selectively, global justice remains rhetorical rather than real.
Finally, the Afghan people’s resistance to these injustices serves as a powerful example for all nations. Despite immense hardship, Afghans continue to demand justice, preserve cultural heritage, and uphold universal human values often in the face of international indifference.
Silence and complacency toward these double standards not only harm public trust but also weaken the moral and legal foundations of the global system. The international community must reassess its policies toward Afghanistan and uphold justice, culture, and human dignity.
Those responsible for destruction must not be rewarded with legitimacy, and international recognition must never come at the expense of universal principles.
The wounds of the Afghan people stand as a historical testimony to the consequences of double standards. True justice in Afghanistan is essential not only for its citizens but also for the preservation of international law and human values. The global community must correct its selective memory, abandon double standards, and take tangible action to safeguard Afghanistan’s rights, heritage, and democratic future.
Call for Support from Civil Societies
The Law and Justice Civil Movement calls upon all Afghan and international civil institutions to stand behind activists, women’s rights defenders, and cultural preservation advocates. We firmly believe that the salvation of a nation lies only through law, justice, education, and freedom. Regimes that promote ignorance inevitably strip nations of their historical identity and moral foundations.
Urgent Appeal to International Organizations
We urge UNESCO, the United Nations, the European Union, and all global human rights institutions to:
Launch a special international initiative for the protection of Afghanistan’s cultural heritage.
Increase global pressure for the reopening of schools and universities for girls.
Support intellectual and civic awareness programs to counter extremist ideologies and promote social enlightenment.
A Call to Save Afghanistan’s Next Generation
Afghanistan’s future generation is perishing under the shadow of ignorance, violence, and extremism. Instead of enlightenment, children are taught submission and fear. If this continues, the intellectual and civil foundations of the nation will inevitably collapse.
We therefore urge the international and regional communities to.
Safeguard the educational rights of Afghan children, girls, and youth from any political or ideological manipulation.
The Law and Justice Civil Movement emphasizes that.
The Afghan people are not the perpetrators of terrorism they are victims, seeking justice, humanity, and freedom. We call for the revival of knowledge, cultural heritage, and social liberty, and we urge the international community to hear the voice of the Afghan nation, not those who have destroyed its culture and future. Global organizations, governments, and civil societies must take practical, sustained, and meaningful action to protect Afghanistan’s next generation. Defending education and awareness is not only a human rights obligation, but also a foundation for regional and global peace.
Dear reader,
Opinions expressed in the op-ed section are solely those of the individual author and do not represent the official stance of our newspaper. We believe in providing a platform for a wide range of voices and perspectives, even those that may challenge or differ from our own. We remain committed to providing our readers with high-quality, fair, and balanced journalism. Thank you for your continued support.