Talk of an EU-wide digital levy is resurfacing as a leading option to help plug the hole in the bloc’s long-term budget, with momentum building behind it just as rival revenue-raising plans run into trouble.
The current draft of the Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF), the EU’s seven-year budget, proposes five new EU-wide taxes (“own resources”): revenue from the Emissions Trading System and Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, a new levy on large company revenue (the Corporate Resource for Europe, or CORE), a charge on non-collected e-waste, and a share of member states’ tobacco and nicotine tax revenue (TEDOR).
Together these were projected to raise €58 billion a year, but several of the proposals are now in doubt, and a digital levy is increasingly being floated to help close the gap.
Czech MEP Danuše Nerudová told Rapporteur this week that a digital levy would help fund the MFF and pay down the EU’s Covid-era debt, adding that
“changes in the attitudes [are happening], including countries that have traditionally been opposed.”
Germany is reportedly among them: according to Politico, Chancellor Friedrich Merz is open to including the levy as part of a Franco-German deal to conclude MFF talks quickly, before French election campaigning begins in earnest next year.
Germany’s past reluctance was largely driven by fears of US retaliatory tariffs. That calculus appears to be shifting: the Republicans’ poor showing in the US midterms has, in the view of some EU figures, reduced the likelihood of a Trump response, making the tax a more palatable option.
The numbers help explain the renewed interest. The Commission’s original estimate for the levy was €5 billion a year, but EU parliamentarians now believe it could raise up to €25 billion — more than double the €11 billion once expected from TEDOR, and a figure that looks even more attractive given TEDOR’s own troubles.
That’s because one of the MFF’s other proposed revenue streams has just hit a wall. EU member states last week failed to agree a revised Tobacco Taxation Directive (TTD), put forward by Ireland in its role holding the EU Council Presidency, after Malta vetoed plans to raise the minimum tax rate on tobacco and nicotine products. The revised proposal had already lowered the minimum rate on nicotine pouches, shrinking the overall revenue estimate.
Even though TTD is not directly related to the EU budget, it has implications for TEDOR’s future because the lower the tobacco and nicotine tax revenue collected from EU member states, the smaller its contribution to the EU’s own resources package will be, and the bigger the shortfall is for the EU’s long-term budget.
That shortfall is now central to the budget negotiations. EU leaders face a choice: pursue a more lucrative but politically riskier digital levy, wait on tobacco taxation talks that may still fall short even if resolved, or turn to higher member state contributions — an option many leaders, several facing elections in 2027, are reluctant to sell at home.
EU Council President António Costa is reportedly set to present a revised MFF later this week focused on new revenue streams, and Nerudová says she’s confident a digital levy will feature in it. Any tax proposal still needs unanimous member state backing, so its fate rests with capitals but with alternative revenue sources faltering, the digital levy debate looks set to keep gathering pace.